Yes I appreciate the economics don’t stack up upon first impressions - but let’s put it this way:
- I was going to buy a brand new Skoda Fabia Estate, from Carwow this would have cost me £16k
- By buying Merlin instead to do the same job, with all parts, accessories, upgrades and repairs included I have spent a total of almost exactly half that, £8246.23!
- Now I accept Merlin is never going to be quite as statistically unlikely to go wrong or need work as a brand new car, but even so, I’ve spent half the amount to get something to do the same job that will cost less in maintenance (as parts will be cheaper and I’ll be more inclined to do more myself from here on) - and crucially, is now an appreciating asset, not a depreciating one.
That last point is important: The Skoda would be worth what I’ve spent on Merlin in less than 4 years I would think.
Actually I thing the logic and chance of repair is stacked in favour of the A2 as compared to new cars it’s electrics are very simple
If you look at what puts cars in the scrap yard these days it’s not rust (as it was 30 years ago) or mechanical failure it is actually electrical issues
We are driving computers on wheels with a modern car and very very few people understand how they work and therefore can diagnose issue that arise. This means practically it a main dealer for the first 3 to 5 years after that the value of the car V the cost of the repair puts it out of main dealer scope
This then leaves you with a few specialist who might charge lass than main dealers but still charge high prices, so this is sustainable until the car is say8 years or older. At this point it would cost more to repair a fault than the car is worth hence it ends up in the breakers yard
Now apply this to the A2, much simpler electronics and a number of members who know the electrics of the car inside out and certainly much better than the dealers now do add to this that they are not charging main dealer prices and I think you will see that the odds are indeed stacked in the A2’s favour
The down side is that if the worst was to happen accident wise then the insurance Co will consider it a 20 years old car and offer little for it. Agreed value insurance is your friend here but takes a little up front planning
The other monkey in the room so to speak is the growing number of low emission zones, we could get to a point where our aluminium chariots are removed from the road by stealth due to the emission side of it.
Even though our tdi’s still put out less CO2 now than a lot of new cars 20 years further up the development ladder do - political madness in my eyes. We need to be looking at the total cost to the environment not just the cars emissions ie what effect on the planet does crushing an A2 to make an electric car really have. Ye at here will be less emissions produces when the car is driven but what about the extra emissions to crush the A2 and manufacture the 4 seater milk float. I suspect the payback will take many years of driving by which time the electric milk float will have developed a fault that no one can work out what it is and I’ve been crushed to make electric milk float mk2
And so it goes on....
Rant over honest
Paul
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk